Browse all reviews by letter     A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 0 - 9

USA 2009
Directed by
Werner Herzog
122 minutes
Rated MA

Reviewed by
Bernard Hemingway
2.5 stars

The Bad Lieutenant: Port Of Call New Orleans

I must say I’ve never thought much of Abel Ferrera’s 1992 Bad Lieutenant which is regarded in some critical quarters very highly and has managed to garner itself cult status. So it's no surprise that I don’t understand why anyone would want to remake it. I understand even less why anyone would get Werner Herzog, an exemplary documentarian to direct what is at best a genre film.  Producer Edward R. Pressman was also producer on the original film but as I understand it this version is Herzog’s and star Nicolas Cage’s baby. Although Ferrera and his  co-writers are credited for the original screenplay, there are those who claim that Port Of Call New Orleans, Herzog’s preferred title for the film, is not a remake of the original. That seems pretty hard to swallow. William Finkelstein's script and setting may be completely different but let’s face it, the film’s about a badly behaving police lieutenant who snorts coke, steals, gambles and extracts sexual favours from his victims. The only real difference to the original is that Cage’s Terence McDonagh actually does some police work.

The film trundles along reasonably well for a while as its tracks McDonagh’s fall from grace in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina during which he sustains a back injury that leaves him with chronic pain and an escalating dependence on pain-killing drugs. He’s losing his shirt to his bookie and his hooker girlfriend (Eva Mendes) gets him involved in a confrontation with a client with Mob connections who wants him to pony up 50 large. It’s all stylishly, if a bit schematically, delivered by Herzog until a scene when McDonagh is trying to fix a speeding ticket for his bookie’s kid and the camera's POV switches to that of an alligator hiding by the roadside. A bit later McDonagh hallucinates an iguana singing Engelbert Humperdinck’s “Please Release Me”.

From this point on, despite Cage’s Klaus Kinski-meets-Harvey Keitel out-of-control performance one can’t help but wonder who Herzog is trying to revenge himself on. Once reaching its outer limit, the plot grows increasingly ludicrous as with facile ease it wraps up everything in McDonagh’s favour, or as the coda show us, not really. If you’re a Val Kilmer fan, don’t bother about this. The actor gets a good billing (which presumably also means a nice paycheck) but he is barely seen, getting one close-up about 40 minutes in then largely disappearing for the rest of the movie. I can imagine some people getting high on the “bliss of evil” which this film depicts but that’s more to do with their propensity for vicariously behaving badly than any merits of Herzog’s film.

DVD Extras: Series of short sound bites with Herzog; Theatrical trailer

Available from: Village Roadshow




Want something different?

random vintage best worst